Mattress Ratings > Mattress Type Comparison
Comparison of Mattress Types → Based on Data From Over 15,000 Actual Owners
Updated August 11, 2011
Pros and Cons of Mattress Types
The pros and cons below are true for each mattress type overall as a group; individual mattresses may have somewhat different pros and cons. Click on a mattress type below for a more detailed evaluation and for brand ratings based on actual owner experiences.
| PROS | CONS | |
|---|---|---|
| Innerspring | Good initial comfort. People are familiar with this type. Some models are inexpensive. |
Below average owner satisfaction. Below average lifespan. Below average pain relief. Motion isolation can be limited. Some noise possible. Usually not dust mite resistant. Many models fairly expensive. |
| Memory Foam | Highest in owner satisfaction. Above average pain relief. Good motion isolation. Several brands/models affordable. No noise. |
Initial odor / off gassing possible. Heat retention possible. Some types difficult to move on. |
| Latex | Above average pain relief. Often firm but comfortable. No noise. Often made of natural material. Good motion isolation. |
Can be pricey. Body impressions possible. Heat retention possible. Initial odor possible. Heavy. |
| Air | Adjustable firmness for each side. Above average pain relief. Above average longevity. Relatively lightweight. |
Some noise from air pumps. Mechanical in nature. Uneven sleep surface possible. Can be expensive. |
| Water | Temperature control. Contours to body. Good longevity possible. Fairly inexpensive. Largely dust mite resistant. |
Can be punctured. Heavy. Set up / assembly. Maintenance needed. Noise and initial odor possible. |
| Futon | Often inexpensive. Duel-use potential. Variety of styles / colors. |
Below average longevity. Too thin / firm for some people. Initial odor possible. |
|
||
16 Areas of Comparison
Each link below provides a comparison of the mattress types (innerspring, memory foam, air, latex, water, futon) for that particular issue.
Overall satisfaction
Affordability
Value
Pain reduction
Firmness
Adjustable firmness
Durability
Longevity
Initial odor / off gassing
Dust mite resistant
Heat retention / sleeping hot
Motion isolation
Flipping / turning requirements
Weight
Noise
Sex friendly