-> Since 2008
-> Unbiased
-> Independent

unbiased Feather Pillow Review, Ratings & Comparisons

Based on 1,574 Consumer Experiences

April 21, 2018

What You Need To Know

THE GOOD: Often soft & moldable • few reports of sleeping hot • above-average longevity • often reasonably priced.

THE BAD: Can lack adequate support & loft • feather quills may poke • potential for noise and odor • may need to be fluffed and shaken to maintain loft / comfort.

THE PILLOWS: They are filled mostly or entirely with feathers from geese and duck. Usually about 5-10% of a feather pillow contains down (the plumage under feathers) to provide additional softness.

THE COMPETITION: Down pillows and down alternative pillows. See how feather pillows compare to these and other types in the pillow reviews summary.

Feather Pillow Ratings: As a Group

Ratings below show how the pillows as a group compare to the average pillow as evaluated by owners. For information on top-rated models, see the following section.

Affordable B They are priced $20-$90 with average being about $31.
Durability / longevity b They tend to have at least a 25% greater lifespan than the average pillow.
Less pain c Feather pillows perform about average overall in regard to providing relief from pain, including neck pain, compared to other pillow types. Feather quills may poke through the cover which can cause discomfort.
Supportive c+ For a significant number of owners, feather pillows flatten excessively when compressed.
Moldable b A moldable pillow is one whose shape can be easily altered or scrunched to increase comfort and support.
Cuddly b A cuddly pillow is one that is soft and huggable, as opposed to hard, rigid, stiff and or heavy.
Short break in B- About three or four night's use on average are required to obtain normal comfort.
Firmness options C- Firmness is almost always considered to be between medium-soft and medium-firm.
Loft options c- Both thicker and thinner feather pillows are available. However, when compressed they tend to have no more than medium loft, regardless of fill quantity.
Contents won't shift C- Feathers may shift to one side resulting in a hollow spot(s).
Back sleep friendly b- Back sleepers are generally satisfied overall. But loft / support may be inadequate for some, namely those with large / heavy heads.
Side sleep friendly b- They often provide the softness side sleepers seek. But loft / support may be inadequate especially for those with large / heavy heads.
Stomach sleep friendly c+ Feather pillows tend to be soft on one's face, but one's face and or upper body may sink in too far to allow for easy breathing. And too high of loft may result in neck or back pain.
Reduces snoring C- Firmer models often perform best on this issue.
No initial odor d+ At least 12% of owners report a lingering and unpleasant odor.
Not a heat trap b Fewer than 3% of owners report excessive heat retention.
No noise d Roughly 15% of owners say that feather pillows make a crunching noise when compressed because feathers can have hard parts or because the pillow has a plastic layer to prevent feathers from poking through.
Fewer allergies c A feather pillow can be allergy causing unless the feathers have been cleaned by having all dander and microbes removed. The pillows may be susceptible to large dust mite populations.
Easy to maintain d Fluffing or shaking is often necessary to return the pillow to its desired loft and or to combat lumpiness. As the pillow ages, increased fluffing / shaking may become necessary.
Ease of cleaning c Some are machine washable. For others, dry cleaning is best.
Easy to lift, turn, move b- Average weight is about 2.5 pounds.

Top-Rated Feather Pillows

The table below evaluates feather pillows with at least 80% owner satisfaction based on 100+ consumer experiences. Important: Information below regarding firmness, loft and sleep position shows what tends to be true for owners. Your own personal evaluation may differ.

Luxury Goose Feather Pillow Original Feather Pillow Old Fashion Style Granny Ticking Feather Pillow Classic Feather Pillow ECB Circle of Down Soft-medium Support Pillows
Owner Satisfaction (sample)          
91% (219) 83% (266) 83% (244) 83% (221) 81% (103) 80% (521)
2 for $60-$80 $78-$90 $33 $20-$25 2 for $30-$45 2 for $55-$60
Sizes Available          
std, qn, king std std, qn, king std/qn, king std, qn, king std, qn, king
med-firm choice of soft, med, firm med med med med-soft
med soft model: low

med model: med

firm model: med-high
med-high med med med
Person Size Best Suited For          
avg soft model: small, avg

med model: avg

firm model: avg, large
avg, large avg avg, small avg, small
Sleeping Position(s) Best Suited For*          
back, side soft model: back, stomach

med model: back, side, perhaps stomach

firm model: back, side
back, side back, side back, side back, side, perhaps stomach
Scrunchable / Moldable          
fair good to fair good to fair good fair good
Ounces of Fill          
30 std
38 qn
45 king
18 std soft
22 std med
26 std firm
32 std
39 qn
47 king
42 std/qn
48 king
29 std
34 qn
35 king
28 std
33 qn
34 king
Return Policy          
30 days 30 days 30 days 30+ days 30 days 30 days
amazon amazon overstock .com jcpenney .com amazon overstock .com

* See the pillow loft guide and loft calculators.

About our feather pillow reviews and research

Our research is based on over 1,500 feather pillow owner reviews and experiences that were collected using an unbiased, accurate methodology.


– About 15% of owners say their feather pillow makes a crunching noise when compressed. This is caused by the fact that feathers can have hard parts or because the pillow has a plastic layer to prevent feathers from poking through.

– At least 12% of owners report a lingering and unpleasant odor (often described as a barnyard-like smell) which may come from the feathers or chemicals used to clean them.

– Fluffing or shaking is often required to maintain pillow loft / height which makes the pillow fairly high maintenance.

– The clear majority of feather pillow owners describe their pillow as medium or soft. Less than 12% describe it as firm.

At Amazon:
A Top-Rated Feather Pillow

SLEEP PRODUCT RESEARCH: Mattress ReviewsMattress Topper ReviewsPillow ReviewsBed Sheet ReviewsWhite Noise Machine ReviewsSleeping Pill ReviewsSleep Hygiene Products

ABOUT SLEEP LIKE THE DEAD: Our StoryContactSitemapPrivacy Policy

AFFILIATE DISCLOSURE: One or more links to a product offered for sale at Amazon.com may appear on this page, and SleepLikeTheDead.com will earn revenue if a product(s) is purchased through such a link(s).

© 2007-2017 SLTD, Inc. • Copyright Violation Notice