Wool Mattress Toppers-Pads → Reviews, Ratings & Complaints Based On Data From 115 Actual Owners
Updated January 22, 2011
What You Need To Know
Owner satisfaction: Wool toppers have 90% owner satisfaction.
Pros: Keeps you fairly cool in summer and warm in winter; natural; generally durable and long lasting.
Cons: May not provide adequate cushioning for some; initial "barnyard" odor possible; pricey.
Price: $130-$300
Competition: See how wool mattress toppers compare to other types in the mattress topper comparison.
Wool Topper-Pad Ratings: As a Group
The ratings below are based on over 100 wool mattress topper owner reviews that were gathered using an unbiased, accurate methodology.
The ratings show how the mattress topper-pads overall are evaluated by owners. For ratings on specific brands, see the section following this one.
| Owner satisfaction | good | Wool toppers have 90% owner satisfaction which rates them similar to or better than other types of mattress toppers. Owner satisfaction is highest among people who seek some (but limited) mattress cushioning as well as temperature control. |
| Durability / longevity | good | Wool toppers generally have above average durability / longevity, but they will likely lose resiliency over time. |
| Price | poor | Prices for wool toppers range from $130-$300. Only latex toppers/pads are pricier. |
| Less pain | fair | Other topper types, such as memory foam and latex, do better on the issue of preventing / relieving pain, including back pain. |
| Motion isolation | poor | Unlike foam toppers, wool does not isolate your movement and keep your movement from disturbing your partner. |
| Easy to move on | good | Unlike memory foam, wool toppers/pads are usually easy to move around on and get up off. |
| Lightweight | good | They are generally less heavy than other types. |
| No initial odor | fair | About 2-5% of owners report an initial "barnyard" smell, but it is usually not severe. |
| No sleeping hot | good | They absorb moisture to keep you fairly cool in summer, warm in winter. |
| Reduced allergies | good | Reduced allergies are occasionally reported. |
| Proper fit / secure | fair | Like many mattress pads, wool pads may not fit properly to the dimensions of the mattress. And they may not stay secure or keep from sliding around somewhat. |
| Appearance | good | When bed is made, a wool pad usually provides a clean, even appearance. |
| Ease of cleaning / maintenance | good | Wool toppers are often machine washable, but may not be machine dryable. Occasional shaking / fluffing may be needed to maintain loft and comfort, especially as topper ages. |
Wool Topper-Pad Ratings: By Brand
The chart below includes only those wool topper-pads for which we could find credible owner experience data. It is not a complete list of wool topper-pads available on the market.
| Topper Brand | Owner Satisfaction | Sample Size | Price (queen) | Retailer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lamb's Wool Mattress Pad | 90% | 101 | $130 | Overstock.com |
SnugFleece Wool Mattress Pad (Amazon) |
90% | 21 | $150-$220 | amazon.com |