Mattress Topper Reviews > Mattress Topper Comparison

Mattress Topper Comparison → Based on Data From Over 10,000 Actual Owners

Updated January 22, 2012


Click on a topper type for more detailed information based on owner data, including brand ratings.

  Memory Foam Feather Fiber Latex Wool
Sample Size 8,238 2,805 743 95 115
Owner Satisfaction 88% 87% 86% 85% 90%
Better Sleep Good Good-Fair Good-Fair Good-Fair Good-Fair
Less Pain Good-Excellent Fair-Good Good-Fair Good Fair-Good
Firmness Medium Soft Soft Soft-Firm Soft
Durability / longevity Fair-Good Good-Fair Fair-Good Fair-Good Good
Price $100 avg $96 avg $48 avg $190 avg $152
Value Good Good-Fair Good-Excellent Fair Good-Fair
Takes Getting Used To Somewhat No No Somewhat No
Ease of Movement Fair-Good Good Good Good-Fair Good
Less Tossing/Turning Good Fair Fair Good Fair-Good
No Sleeping Hot Fair Good-Fair Good-Fair Fair-Good Good-Fair
Maintenance Low Medium-High Medium Low Medium
Allergies / Dust Mites Medium Medium Medium-High Medium Medium-Low
No Initial Odor Poor-Fair Fair-Good Good-Excellent Fair-Good Fair
Stays Secure Fair Fair Fair Fair Fair
Fits Properly Fair Fair Fair Fair Fair
Appearance Good Fair-Good Fair-Good Good Good
Ease of Cleaning Fair Fair Fair Fair Good-Fair

 

 

About our unbiased mattress topper reviews and research

Our mattress topper research is based on a sample size of over 10,000 actual owner experiences.

In addition, each individual topper (memory foam, latex, wool, fiber, feather) has a sample size of several hundred. The owner experience data was collected from diverse credible sources.

The result is a sampling error of ±4 percentage points. We believe this because no matter how much data (information from owner reviews / comments) we add to each mattress topper type, our findings do not extend beyond a range of a few percentage points.