Mattress Ratings > Mattress Retailer Comparison
Page last updated December 4, 2010
The following comparison includes many of the largest national and regional mattress retailers in the United States. "NA" below means that reliable information is not currently available. If you know of information below that needs to be updated / corrected, please contact us.
| Locations | Mattress Brands Sold | Delivery Services | Return Policy | Better Business Bureau Rating | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cost | Time | Setup | Old Mattress Removal | Length | Exchange and or Refund | Fee | ||||||||
| US-mattress.com | Nationwide -- online or phone sales. Michigan stores. | Bassett, Sealy (Posturepedic, Trueform, Springfree, Embody), Serta, Simmons (Beautyrest, Comforpedic, Nxg), Spring Air, Stearns & Foster, Tempurpedic | Free delivery | Up to 2 weeks to deliver | Set up is $149 and only available for Stears & Foster | Removal $99, but free for Stears & Foster | 100 days to return | Exchange only | $99 processing fee and redelivery fee | C | ||||
| 1800mattress.com | Nationwide -- online or phone sales only | King Koil, Sealy Serta, Simmons, Stearns & Foster, Tempurpedic, W Hotel | Free delivery | Next day delivery to most areas | Setup free | Free move to curb | 21 days to return | Exchange only | $80-$130 fee depending on mattress size | A- | ||||
| Ashley Furniture Home Store | Most states | Sealy (Embody, Posturepedic), Simmons (Beautyrest, Comforpedic), Stearns & Foster, store brand (Memory foam and latex) |
Policies determined by each store | Policies determined by each store | Policies determined by each store | Policies determined by each store | Policies Determined by each store | Policies Determined by each store | Policies Determined by each store | Headquarters: A+ Individual stores may Vary |
||||
| Brookstone | Most states | Tempurpedic | Delivery may be free |
5-10 days to deliver | Setup free | Removal not available | 90 days to return | Exchange or refund | Return shipping free. | A+ | ||||
| Costco | Most states | Novaform/Sleep Innovations, Sealy, Sleep Science, Stearns & Foster | Free delivery | Up to 4-6 weeks for delivery | Setup free | Removal not available | 90 days or more to return | Exchange or refund | Redelivery fee if exchanged | Headquarters: B+ Individual stores may Vary |
||||
| JCPenney | Most states | Laura Ashley, Sealy , Serta, Simmons, Stearns & Foster | Delivery not free | Up to 2 weeks for delivery | Setup available | NA | 90 days to return | Exchange or refund | Redelivery fee if exchanged | Headquarters: A+ Individual stores may Vary |
||||
| Macy's | Most states | Aireloom, Sealy Posturepedic, Simmons (Beautyrest, Black, NXG), Serta, Stearns & Foster, Tempurpedic | Mattress sets priced $799 and over are eligible for free delivery. | Up to 6 business days for delivery | Setup available | NA | 60 days to return | Exchange only | You pay original delivery, $70 for redelivery, plus 10% handling fee | Accredited | ||||
| Sams | Most states | Aerus, American Sleep Collection, Nature's Sleep, Night Therapy, Serta, Sleep Visco, waterbeds | Free delivery | 10-12 business days to deliver | Free setup | Removal not available | 90 days or more to return | Exchange or refund | Redelivery fee if exchanged | Headquarters: not accredited Individual stores have own rating |
||||
| Sears | Most states | King Koil, Laura Ashley, Natura, Sealy, Sears-o-pedic, Serta, Simmons Beautyrest, Stearns & Foster | Delivery not free |
7-12 days to deliver | Setup available | Removal $10 | 30 days to return | Exchange or refund | 15% restocking fee and if exchanged redelivery fee | Headquarters: A- Individual stores may Vary |
||||
| Wal-Mart / walmart.com | Most states | Futons (Otis, Simmons), Sealy, Simmons, Serta, Spa Sensations, Strobel (Supplepedic, Supplerest) |
Delivery not free. |
7-14 days to deliver | No setup | No removal | 90 days to return | Exchange or refund | Redelivery fee if exchanged | walmart.com: A+ Individual stores may Vary |
||||
| Sit 'n Sleep | CA | Aireloom, Miralux, Sealy (Posturepedic, Embody), Serta, Simmons, Stearns & Foster, Tempurpedic | Free delivery | NA | Setup available | Removal for small fee | 60 days to return | Exchange only | 20% restocking fee, redelivery fee | Individual stores have own rating | ||||
| Sleep Train | CA | Sealy, Serta Vera Wang, Simmons, Stearns & Foster, Tempurpedic | Free delivery | Same day delivery available | Free setup | Free removal | 100 days to return | Exchange or refund | NA | Headquarters: A+ Individual stores may Vary |
||||
| RC Willey | UT, NV, ID, CA | Ecomfort, Simmons, Serta, Aireloom, Spring Air, Tempurpedic | Free delivery may be available on some models | NA | NA | NA | 60 days to return | Exchange only | 10% handling and redelivery fee | Headquarters: A Individual stores may Vary |
||||
| Sleep Country | WA, OR | Sealy, Serta, Simmons, Stearns & Foster, Tempurpedic | Free delivery | NA | Free setup | Free removal | 100 days to return | Exchange or refund | NA | Individual stores have own rating | ||||
| Slumberland | WI, MN, IA, ND, SD, NE, KS, MO, IL | Sealy, Simmons, Stearns & Foster, Tempurpedic | Delivery not free | NA | Setup not free | Removal available | 60 days to return | Exchange or store credit | Redelivery fee | Headquarters: A+ Individual stores may Vary |
||||
| Art Van Furniture | Michigan | King Koil, Natura, Sealy, Simmons, Stearns & Foster, Tempurpedic |
Delivery not free | NA | Setup free | Removal not available | 45 days to return | Exchange only | $119 fee plus redelivery fee | A+ | ||||
| Mattress Firm | AL, AZ, CO, FL, GA, IL, IN, KS, KY, LA, MO, MS, NC, NM, NV, NY, OH, OK, SC, TN, TX, WI | Sealy, Simmons, Stearns & Foster, Tempurpedic | Delivery not free | Same or next day delivery | Free setup | Free removal | 100 days to return | Exchange or refund | Redelivery fee if exchanged | Headquarters: B- Individual stores may Vary |
||||
| Sleep Experts | Dallas, Texas Metroplex | Aireloom, Laura Ashley, Life Number, Simmons (Beautyrest, Comforpedic, Natural Care), Sleep Designs, Tempurpedic | Delivery not free | NA | Free setup | Free removal | 1 year to return | Exchange only | No fees | Individual stores have own rating | ||||
| Mattress Discounters | MD, VA, AL, DC, DE | Sealy, Stearns & Foster, Tempurpedic, Europa | Delivery not free | NA | Setup available | Free removal | 60 days to return | Exchange only | Fees apply | Headquarters: A+ Individual stores may Vary |
||||
| Sleepy's | Northeast and Mid-Atlantic | King Koil, Laura Ashley, Miralux, Pure Latex Bliss, Sealy, Serta, Simmons, Comforpedic, Simmons, Stearns & Foster, Tempurpedic | Delivery not free | NA | Setup not free | Removal available | 21 days to return | Exchange only | $150-$400 fee depending on mattress size plus redelivery fee | Headquarters: A+ Individual stores may Vary |
||||
| Mattress Giant | DE, FL, TX, GA, IL, NH, NJ, PA, | Sealy Simmons Stearns & Foster Tempurpedic |
Delivery not free | NA | Free setup | Free removal | 100 days to return | Exchange only | $175 exchange fee includes redelivery | Headquarters: C+ Individual stores may Vary |
||||
|
||||||||||||||